Welcome to

          shorthairs.net

  Login  Register Saturday, May 25, 2013     
Subject: OFA rating question...dysplasia lurking??
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Page 1 of 212 > >>
Author Messages
CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/18/2009 2:29 PM  

We are considering a pup from a bitch who's first litter is this one.  She's just under two yrs of age and thus does not yet have a hip rating.  Breeder seems very responsible, provided references from other pups from other female they own and all seem satisfied.  they have a contract and health guarnantee (though I have yet to review).  their females produce one litter per year maximum.

the mother of our litter seems healthy, comes from sound rated dame and sire and the father of this litter has a sound OFA rating. 

If there's no history of displasia in the bloodline is this too much of a gamble?? 

Also, please tell me your stories as to pups that end up with dysplasia...can't imagine sending an pup back after +1 yr or after my daughter(and me for that matter) have connected with the pup...however, we had a dog who ended up with genetic-isms and it was more like a cat-dog (not what I want again.  Do people send dogs back, really? 

I'm a little paranoid because friends of ours have a 8month old Golden with dysplasia and all are disappointed (they didn't do much homework knowing them though).

CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/19/2009 8:48 PM  
No responses...have I crossed over in to a taboo line of questioning?
pixie beeUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:4452


02/20/2009 6:20 AM  
You say the mother SEEMS healthy. What does that mean? By looking at her you could not see anything wrong.

What is the reason for breeding her before 2 y.o. and before her hips were done? Why not wait for the next cycle?

What is so special about this litter and breeder that you think you should get a puppy from them?

You say the breeder seems very responsible, based on what criteria?
T
hese are just a few questions, I really didn't want to get carried away.

Francine



"Time with my dogs clears my mind, renews my faith, and lets me see the world as it is. My only regret loving dogs as I do, is the misery of their early departure." Robert G. Wehle
bravepointUser is Offline
North Gower, ON Canada
MH
MH
Posts:894


02/20/2009 7:18 AM  
Is the breeder going to do the hips of this female after the litter is born? Are there any other health clearances on her? If she happens to get a dysplastic OFA rating, do you have any recourse?

Yes, people really do send pups back.

If you have any reservations about the litter, I'd say go elsewhere. There are too many good dogs with full health clearances being bred. Of course, anything can happen even with OFA ratings of excellent....

Gail

Gail, Moka, Avery, Terra & Rayne
Bravepoint GSPs
singltrakUser is Offline
Las Cruces, NM
MH
MH
Posts:1149


02/20/2009 7:25 AM  
I think, personally, that you are getting more excited about the possibility of hip dysplasia than you need to be. (That said, all my breeding stock is CHIC certified-hips, cardiac, CERF and CD or will be before it is bred). If one has bred a number of litters, certified or not, OFA or Penn Hip or not, the chances are that you will see a bit of everything. Health testing does not necessarily mean that the ugly spectre of congenital defects may not rear its ugly head, but it certainly lessens the chances.

As far as returning puppies who don't meet health clearances, that is up to the individual breeder, and something you need to discuss with them fully. Most people are perfectly willing to refund a portion of your investment providing proof of spay or neuter is given. Few people would make you send a puppy back that you are attached to though there are some. Just get it in writing and make sure you and the breeder are on the same page.


Phyllis and the Singltrak Furtribe
www.singltrakshorthairs.net/

Look to the Past, Breed for the Future
CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/20/2009 7:56 AM  
Not sure yet about recourse. But I'll find out....it seems that if I don't have recourse, that says a lot about the breeders confidence in the dog / bloodline.

Is it reasonable to expect that if the dog develops dysplasia or other (elbow / eye) problems that are congenital related issues that they take the dog back and give us first pick from their next litter? not say that's what we would do as we'll be completely attached, but "yes" to that question provides a lot of assurance / comfort for me as even the best rating won't be a 100% guarantee.

This breeder will provide a health guarnatee which I have yet to review. How common is this having the right to pick from the next litter in a breeders contract / health guarantees?
pixie beeUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:4452


02/20/2009 8:17 AM  
cornbread,
how about answering my quetions?

you are concerned about hip testing but in my eyes there are many other considerations that make a responsible breeder and a quality litter.
And you have not read the health guarentee yet, has it not been provided yet?


"Time with my dogs clears my mind, renews my faith, and lets me see the world as it is. My only regret loving dogs as I do, is the misery of their early departure." Robert G. Wehle
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7856


02/20/2009 9:48 AM  

A good breeder will generally provide a contract and guarantee with their dog, some even have new buyer policies and questionaires.  I suggest getting those documents and reading them first, then if you have questions ask the breeder.  Good breeders are open to discussion and anything within reason is possible, including a breeder taking back a dog, giving you choice in the next litter, giving you a partial refund, etc.  It sounds like from your initial post that the breeder is responsible.  Some folks won't breed a shorthair at that age and some won't breed until they have all the health clearances, but I don't think we know the circumstances yet of why this bitch was bred.  Maybe it was an accident, but still good parents and hopefully good pups.  So, do your homework and then have a conversation with the breeder.  After that only you can judge, but use your head and your heart in that judgement.  Good luck!!


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
DesertRoseKennelUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:1033


02/20/2009 9:56 AM  

We've never dealt with dysplasia personally - however we certify all dogs before ever considering breeding. Phyllis is right - dysplastic hips are very rare in the breed. Having said that, I personally wouldn't take the risk. My vet tells of a 12 yr old GSP he cared for who had been a die-hard personal gundog nutjob runner for the first 12 years of his life. He finally started favoring his hip at that late stage and his owners brought him in. My vet was shocked at the xrays - they showed a ball joint that was shattered into a million pieces. And from the calcification, he was confident it had happened when the dog was young. While this wasn't dysplasia, it proves to me that GSPs especially cannot be judged by how they look or move. I get into arguments with fellow field trialers about this. Many of them believe that if a dog can run field trials (especially all age) without being lame, their hips are fine. Not necessarily so.

I personally would at a minimum want to see preliminary xrays done on the dam. Additionally breeding a dog before age two is not a great idea in my book - she hasn't truly proven herself and many things can pop up at later ages.


"Our dogs are bred to be champion hunters who sleep on the bed"
www.desertrosekennel.com
pixie beeUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:4452


02/20/2009 9:58 AM  

"the mother of our litter seems healthy, comes from sound rated dame and sire and the father of this litter has a sound OFA rating. "

 

Can you offer more details on what this means?I have no idea how to interpret what you mean by this.

 

 

 



"Time with my dogs clears my mind, renews my faith, and lets me see the world as it is. My only regret loving dogs as I do, is the misery of their early departure." Robert G. Wehle
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7856


02/20/2009 11:05 AM  
Posted By DesertRoseKennel on 02/20/2009 9:56 AM

While this wasn't dysplasia, it proves to me that GSPs especially cannot be judged by how they look or move. I get into arguments with fellow field trialers about this. Many of them believe that if a dog can run field trials (especially all age) without being lame, their hips are fine. Not necessarily so.

I would second this.  Belle tore her bicep tendon in her front right shoulder when she was about 9 months old.  The only indication that anything was wrong was when I would put her in a long sit she would continually shift her front feet around.  This was out of character for her.  When I took her to the vet initially they thought I was nuts, especially when the first xray didn't show anything conclusive.  I persisted and finally 6 months later an orthopedic surgeon took another xray and it showed the damage.  Prior to taking the xray though the surgeon had manipulated her shoulder and had about decided there was no issue, and then took the xray just as a precaution.  When he came back to show me the results he said "this dog should have bitten my head off when I manipulated her leg."  GSPs can withstand allot of pain, and ofter display injuries in very subtle ways.


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/20/2009 7:52 PM  
More details from the source which prompted the original post / question (we talked by phone this evening):

1) When the dam's sister was OFA rated they "putting her on the table and the process of taking the xrays is such that they get stretched out and it made her really sore". So sore that she was not back to normal activity for more than a week and the breeder said that "it made her miss her next cycle".

2) Is this common and expected for the rating process? Is it or should it have such an impact on either sore muscles and or effecting hormones?

3) As to why breed prior to 2nd birthday?...they wanted to wait until her 2nd cycle and they don't track it according to date of birth.

This makes sense but I've heard some folks rail on an ethics basis about not breeding prior to 2nd birthday.

4. They do guarantee hips for 2 yrs and said (have yet to see the contract) that if the pup develops dyplasia we could return it and pick from their next litter.

This is important to me because it says they stand behind the dog.

5. Breeder said that the sire's parents are rated...should I ask for a copy / proof of this along with pedigree family tree thing to see his parents and g-parents? Is this a reasonable request?

Thanks for all the thoughts prior and those you'll post...it's all very helpful!!





DesertRoseKennelUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:1033


02/20/2009 9:04 PM  

My thoughts on each item below:

1) When the dam's sister was OFA rated they "putting her on the table and the process of taking the xrays is such that they get stretched out and it made her really sore". So sore that she was not back to normal activity for more than a week and the breeder said that "it made her miss her next cycle".

This is a load of hooey, I'm sorry. I would actually be worried if my dog was sore after OFA xrays. Either the vet was way too heavy handed, or the dog really struggled and should have been sedated - or perhaps has issues with its hips. Mine don't require sedation - so I don't have personal experience there. I would highly doubt that would make a bitch miss a cycle. Sounds like excuses why they don't want to pay for certification.

3) As to why breed prior to 2nd birthday?...they wanted to wait until her 2nd cycle and they don't track it according to date of birth.

Personal opinion again - but the second cycle is WAY too early. I still stand by my earlier statement. To intentionally breed before the age of 2 is a bad idea. Besides all the things that can crop up later, a bitch under two isn't done growing herself and isn't physically or mentally ready to be a mama.

4. They do guarantee hips for 2 yrs and said (have yet to see the contract) that if the pup develops dyplasia we could return it and pick from their next litter.

If one pup is dysplastic, why would you want another from their line? Something to think about. And just because a dog makes it to age 2 without dysplasia does not mean it won't develop later.

This is important to me because it says they stand behind the dog.

5. Breeder said that the sire's parents are rated...should I ask for a copy / proof of this along with pedigree family tree thing to see his parents and g-parents? Is this a reasonable request?

I take this to mean that the sire isn't certified either? The breeder should be offering the pedigree without you having to ask. You can look up the dogs in the pedigree on the OFFA site to verify.

My two cents - too many things would concern me here personally. However, it is your choice.

Jean


 


"Our dogs are bred to be champion hunters who sleep on the bed"
www.desertrosekennel.com
singltrakUser is Offline
Las Cruces, NM
MH
MH
Posts:1149


02/21/2009 7:30 AM  
Everything Jean said and more. Unless PennHip was used as the method of Hip rating, there's no reason WHATSOEVER for a dog to be "sore" following OFA x-rays. Mine are usually given some Torbutrol for mild sedation, but "loopy" would be a term I'd use for their reactions. (Ever put a spider on its back? That would describe my Hailey without sedation- vbg).

Many, many things concern me here, and too many well bred puppies out there for me to go there. Providing you with a pedigree should be a given. If you want to, post the names of the sire and dam and we can look them up on the OFA website and determine what health testing they've had (if any). Or, you can also, the URL is www.offa.org .

You are doing a great job doing your homework. Keep it up.

Phyllis

Look to the Past, Breed for the Future
CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/21/2009 7:43 AM  
Thanks to all for the feedback...we are headed away from this breeder...decision in the coming weeks. In the meantime I've spend the morning search for other breeders in and around our state. That additionally may make our minds up.
thanks for your patience ...I'm sure I'll look back and it will all be clear...probably clouded a little now by our desire to bring a pup home...just have to think about 15 yrs not a few months.
Many thanks to you all!
DesertRoseKennelUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:1033


02/21/2009 9:39 AM  

just have to think about 15 yrs not a few months

That is EXACTLY what you should be thinking. If everyone made puppy buying decisions that way puppy mills would go out of business. Congratulations on using your head, not your heart, to make the decision. That's not easy to do.

Jean


"Our dogs are bred to be champion hunters who sleep on the bed"
www.desertrosekennel.com
Almost Heaven GSPUser is Offline
Springfield, WV
MH
MH
Posts:731


02/21/2009 10:11 AM  
I'll 3rd Jean and 2nd Phyllis!
1 additional thought from my peanut gallery.... They Guarantee the pup until the age of 2, but you would be unable to get an OFA Cert. until AFTER 2, which would "suggest" the pup would then be outside of the age range of the Guarantee.....
Of course, you could pay to have X-rays taken at 1 1/2 or so and submit them to OFA for a Preliminary Rating to see how they appeared within the Guarantee period, but then if you wanted an official rating you would have to pay again to have them done again after 2 years of age.
Just my thoughts...

Money will buy a fine dog, but only kindness will make him wag his tail.

Bruce Shaffer
Almost Heaven GSP's
CornbreadUser is Offline

SH
SH
Posts:50


02/21/2009 11:11 AM  
So it sounds as though a 24 month hip guarantee is basically worthless. Is that correct? I saw one recently from another breeder that was 26 months...seems more appropriate and in fact useful.

So on the next issue...should I focus at all on the dam and sires elbows and eyes? Any guidance would be helpful.
singltrakUser is Offline
Las Cruces, NM
MH
MH
Posts:1149


02/21/2009 4:11 PM  
Elbows maybe. Eyes are a given. I'd look for sire and dam if possible to be CHIC certified (that means they have participated in health testing for hips, cardiac, CERF and CD (both eyes). You don't say where you live, but the National Specialty will be held over Mother's Day weekend in Denver Colorado (more information at www.gspca.org), and there will be plenty of GSPs, and possibly puppies, as well as breeders there to talk to and visit with. As Jean and Bruce and Francine have all said, its good that you are doing your homework and thinking ahead 15 years. There is an old bumper sticker which says, "a dog is for life, not just for Christmas". Sounds like you are really thinking that way and I thank you for that.

Just had a 16 month old returned to me for being a "teenaged shorthair", mostly. People tend too many times to look at the puppies and see cute, and don't think down the road til they turn into "denizens of the back yard".

Phyllis

Look to the Past, Breed for the Future
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7856


02/21/2009 6:08 PM  

If it helps any at all, my breeder for my three still stays in touch with me and actually posts Halo's wins and brags on her website with pictures.  I can go to her anytime for advice.  I am now on my second pup from this breeder (my male Ringo) and I count my breeder as a good friend.  Questions (of which I have many) are always answered and we stay pretty much in touch all the time.  That is the level of interest I would expect of a breeder of any pup I would purchase. The first conversation I ever had with this breeder lasted well over an hour.  Both of us were interviewing the other.  All of her dogs and pedigrees are posted with all health clearances on her website.  She never breeds her bitches before about 4 years of age and typical only does one litter every two to three years. I generally get a call from her whenever she is thinking about breeding because she knows how I treat the pups.  Anyway, the only reason I posted this is to give you an idea of what to look for in a breeder and the relationship between you and your breeder. Anything less and I would walk away.


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 212 > >>

Forums > General > Breeding > OFA rating question...dysplasia lurking??



ActiveForums 3.7
 Private Message Count
Minimize
You must be logged in to use this module.
UsersOnline
Membership Membership:
Latest New User Latest: hsemaan
New Today New Today: 1
New Yesterday New Yesterday: 1
User Count Overall: 3209

People Online People Online:
Visitors Visitors: 108
Members Members: 0
Total Total: 108

Online Now Online Now:
 Print   
Home  |  Events  |  Blogs  |  Photo Gallery  |  GSP Forum
 Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement | WHC DNN Site 
Copyright 2008-2011 by Rick Petersen