Welcome to

          shorthairs.net

  Login  Register Wednesday, June 19, 2013     
Subject: quail vs. pigeon
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Author Messages
Rcook1818User is Offline


Posts:2


02/03/2009 10:19 AM  

Hello,

I'm new here and looking for some advice.  I will be training a new GSP pup this summer for the first time on my own.  My question is when I'm ready to introduce birds which is better, Quail or Pigeons?  I have been reading a lot and the more I read the more indecisive I get about it.  Seems like there are valid arguements for both out there.  Any opinions/ advice is greatly appreciated.

pixie beeUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:4476


02/03/2009 12:04 PM  
I don't know that there is a a controversy over the which bird to use and which not to use.


"Time with my dogs clears my mind, renews my faith, and lets me see the world as it is. My only regret loving dogs as I do, is the misery of their early departure." Robert G. Wehle
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7926


02/03/2009 12:09 PM  

I too am fairly new to training a GSP to hunt.  So, here is what I experienced when I introduced my male pup to birds at 4 months.  I went to a fun hunt day at the GSP bird lease that belongs to the GSP club in San Antonio.  They have homing pidgeons and they also had bought quail to plant for the dogs when they ran in practice braces.  Ringo had never been introduced to birds, so that morning I worked with one of the experienced club members and we used pidgeons to introduce Ringo to birds and get him excited.  They told me they use pidgeons because they are cheaper (homing pidgeons can be used over and over) and they fly much better than the store bought quail.  So, Ringo was introduced to birds with pidgeons and he figured it out quickly and got really excited.  So then we added in the gun using a starter pistol. 

Later in the morning I ran him in a brace with the quail marked where they were planted.  The dog he was paired with was experienced.  After the older dog found the first couple of quail and he figured out what was going on (I took him over to where the other dog had found the quail and let him get a nose full), he found the last planted quail on his own.  That afternoon the quail had been scattered all over the place as there had been many braces run that morning, we took Ringo out in another brace with a dog of about his same level.  He never hesitated, he got out in front of the other dog and proceeded to find all of the birds and point them.  I pulled him off the course about 2/3 of the way through so the other dog could find some birds and also Ringo was a very tired boy.

My opinion after this experience is it doesn't really matter.  The dogs are smart enough to figure it out. Ringo even points my pet cockatiel in her cage in the house from time to time.


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
RugergundogUser is Offline
Saginaw Michigan USA
MH
MH
Posts:395


02/09/2009 11:06 AM  
There is indeed a difference!!!! I will share my experience. Comparing healthy strong birds of each species.

* Pigeons are stronger flying birds hands down! +
* Wet Pigeons can still fly
* Pigeons are cheaper birds hands down! +
* Pigeons give of a game bird scent, but rarely are used in any sort of test and rarely are hunted. Though it is upland bird scent it is unique to the bird (-)

So with that added I now opt to use pigeons when there are issues of the dog not holding point and trying to catch the bird. They can get up and fly very very good even when wet. And when trying to expose the dog to situations that you will not shoot (he busted the bird) and you see your $$$ fly away, cheap is better. $4-5 a pair you can get 4 of them plant them and do a $10 training a couple times and most dogs will begin to understand they gotta hold point for you to shoot and them to get a bird in mouth. I pay $4.25 for Tenn Red Quail.

Later in training when the basics are down i change over to quail, chucker, ringnecks since they have more the specific upland scent and taste of my desired hunting targets. I go to ringnecks last as a wounded (and pricey) bird can kick a young dog with a spur and miss with his confidence.

If anyone would like i can show you my homemade pigeon trap. I put it out in my area at farms and catch birds at times to use for little training sessions. Most of the time they don't even get shot when working a puppy.

Saginaw Michigan
Brittany- Ruger
GSP- Kilian
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7926


02/09/2009 11:10 AM  

I would love to see your homemade pidgeon trap and also any plans if you have them.  Do you think the pidgeon trap would also work on white wing doves.  We have a ton of doves in our area as well as pidgeons.  The doves fly pretty good too and I could set the trap in the yard for the doves. I would have to trap pidgeons elsewhere.


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
RugergundogUser is Offline
Saginaw Michigan USA
MH
MH
Posts:395


02/09/2009 11:38 AM  

ill post up the way i made it along with some pictures.  Cost me $15 to make total.

 

Yea it will work on doves, i catch those also.


Saginaw Michigan
Brittany- Ruger
GSP- Kilian
Texas BelleUser is Offline
Austin, TX
MH
MH
Posts:7926


02/09/2009 11:39 AM  

Thanks Ruger!


Bev Quarles, the Pointer Sisters (Belle and Halo), the Outlaw GSP (Johnny Ringo) and the little Princess (Fauna)

Yellow Rose GSPs

 photo FaunaBISJan20110001cropped_resized_zps96af44b6.jpg  photo DSC_0044_cropped_zps0a25f9ff.jpg  photo DSC_0030a_zps3c822a4a.jpg  photo DSC_0016cropped_zpsab533745.jpg

"A dog has the soul of a philosopher." - Plato
Rcook1818User is Offline


Posts:2


02/09/2009 10:17 PM  

I'd also like to see the plans for that pigeon trap.  Thanks for the help. 

ErricUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:95


02/11/2009 6:00 AM  
So how about those plans? I'm interested as well.
RugergundogUser is Offline
Saginaw Michigan USA
MH
MH
Posts:395


02/11/2009 6:34 AM  
Sorry guys, just been busy with the dogs and this warm weather, pics will be posted up tonight along with some plans.

Saginaw Michigan
Brittany- Ruger
GSP- Kilian
TreyUser is Offline
SW Iowa
MH
MH
Posts:516


02/12/2009 6:21 AM  
I introduce (show very young (5-8) week old pups to quail, pull flights and let the pups chase them around. Then when I put them on birds when they are a few weeks older it is straight to pigeons in launchers. The reasons: they will never catch one on the ground, pigeons fly almost straight up and away the pup learns chasing will not get it anywhere , quail fly straight and low, enticing pup to chase and often rewarding it by landing where pup can get it again.
I have found with pigeons in launchers, most well bred pups (meaning normal pointing instinct and some cooperation) will steady themselves to wing (stand until the bird is in the air) on their own. JMO
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > General > Training > quail vs. pigeon



ActiveForums 3.7
 Private Message Count
Minimize
You must be logged in to use this module.
UsersOnline
Membership Membership:
Latest New User Latest: NDScoutfam
New Today New Today: 3
New Yesterday New Yesterday: 1
User Count Overall: 3254

People Online People Online:
Visitors Visitors: 111
Members Members: 1
Total Total: 112

Online Now Online Now:
01: kpwlee
 Print   
Home  |  Events  |  Blogs  |  Photo Gallery  |  GSP Forum
 Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement | WHC DNN Site 
Copyright 2008-2011 by Rick Petersen