Many people say German Shorthairs cannot compete with other waterfowl dogs and are not meant to be duck dogs. Are they right? 

    I have a 13 month old GSP. She is not my first dog but she is my first GSP and will hopefully be my first four legged hunting companion. I do not know about other owners but for me there were several things that appealed to me about getting a German Shorthaired Pointer. One being there sleek and athletic appearance in addition to their energetic personality. However, the most endearing attribute for me is their versatility as a hunting dog and companion.

    I like to do several types of hunting but where I live here in GA unless I happen to become friends with a wealthy land barren, waterfowl is the hunting she and I will be doing the most. That being said I have read and have personally experienced frequent ridicule for selecting a GSP to be a duck dog. I know that they are not the most popular "duck dog" according to many however they are the most popular dog for me but I am starting to lose faith in her becoming a duck dog.

    Sydney has been fast to learn and eager to please. She is very energetic and shows a strong desire to chase or track anything that would be consider wild game. That being said I have a couple of large problems that I can see with my pup. One she is gun shy and being that she is my first hunting dog I am not sure of how to break her of it.
   
    As she has gotten older she has lost desire to retrieve...frizby, ball, rope, canvas dummy or training dummy it doesn't matter. If she shows any interest at all she prances to the object (does not run) and when it stops she moves on to something that she finds more interesting whether it be a flower or whatever catches her eye.

    Finally the final draw back for my dream duck dog is that she is nervous in the water. She loves to play at the river and in the shallow water. I have been taking her since she first came home but if she has to swim she will usually not go into the water.

    I know much of it is my fault and lack of knowledge on my part. However, I do not want her to suffer or not rise to her full potential because of my ignorance. I need help and fact of the matter is it is not something that I can just throw money at to solve my problem. I know that it takes time and patience...those things I do have I just need help with the steps and some encouragement that I am not alone.

    I tried taking her for an hour session with a professional retriever trainer. He offered some helpful advice. Try live birds and feathers, get her excited about retrieving and start her in shallow water and slowly transition to deep water retrievals. Also start with a smaller caliber gun at a distance and work closer to her while giving her positive reinforcement. These things make sense to me but even that being said he felt the time and energy I would spend in this endeavor that I may come out better or with a better finished product if I were to start over from scratch.
   
    The trainer of course tried to encourage me towards a labrador retriever instead but I don't want a labrador and my stubborn nature just feels more compelled to work harder with my GSP. He basically did not see them as equals when compared to a labrador; whether it be in competition or actual hunting and retrieving. I know different breads may be more suited for different types of hunting and I also know that within a bread of dog you still have different personalities the same as people. Is my dog just not of the right personality, am I asking her to do something that she is not well suited for or have I just neglected her training? What can I do to turn this around?

    All comments and feedback is welcome.

Thank you,

Paul