Welcome to

          shorthairs.net

  Login  Register Wednesday, June 19, 2013     
Subject: [working-gundog] displacement behaviours
Prev Next
You are not authorized to post a reply.

Author Messages
cwaltUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:180


12/20/2007 12:10 PM  
The dog is retrieving a quail in a round-about path back to the handler. The dog veers off the line around a clump of brush. The handler repeats the command "fetch" in a positive and dominant way. The dog crunches the quail and we hear bones breaking. That is the start of a problem, a serious one, and illustrates displacement behavior. Nikko Tinbergen clarified displacement behavior in seagulls by noting that two rival gulls often displayed grass pulling behavior to each other. The grass pulling took place at the peak of a territorial conflict and the two gulls, seemingly ready to attack each other, turn aside and tear up grass clumps. This odd behavior appears to result from a conflict, a desire to attack and a fear of being attacked. The result of the conflict is displacement behavior, if faced with a difficult choice the animal does something else to release the tension. In the confronted gull it's grass tearing, in the conflicted dog it's crunching a bird. The retrieving dog is faced with a conflict, it doesn't want to come to the handler but the command to retrieve is forceful, the dog hesitates and does something other than refusing the command, it crushes the bird. In this particular conflict of emotions the displacement behavior can be repeated if the command to 'fetch' is repeated. The immediate result, a crushed and worthless bird, isn't about the bird, it's about the dog's fear of approaching a tyrannical trainer/handler. It is possible that a silent handler would have resulted in an undamaged bird being dropped at his feet. The crushed bird isn't the dog's fault, the trainer that did such a poor job of teaching the dog to retrieve caused the problem. Cj
rospiganUser is Offline

MH
MH
Posts:372


12/21/2007 2:00 AM  
>>>handler but the command to retrieve is forceful, the dog hesitates and does
something other than refusing the command, it crushes the bird.  In this
particular conflict of emotions the displacement behavior can be repeated if
the command to 'fetch' is repeated.  The immediate result, a crushed and
worthless bird, isn't about the bird, it's about the dog's fear of
approaching a tyrannical trainer/handler.   It is possible that a silent
handler would have resulted in an undamaged bird being dropped at his feet.
The crushed bird isn't the dog's fault,  the trainer that did such a poor
job of teaching the dog to retrieve caused the problem.
Cj>>>
 
And hence it is such a pity that they disqualify  spaniels that have a "hard mouth" in the trials......... They also disqualify spaniels that makes a sound twice in a trial . A warning is given after the first sound. Anyway, in both cases the problem most often, although not always, can be found in the leadership.
 
The trial is used as a selecting tool but it has a very large mesh. Together with the genetically really though cases, many times more of good dogs that have been ignorantly trained will fall through into the dustbin.  
 
Talking about displacement behaviours I remember particularly one and the "behaviourist" was my late Springer the spaniel. It is a little difficult to explain but I'll try anyway:
 
Springer developed a social problem at an age of say 6 - 7 years. When she was alone with other dogs, dogs she knew or did not know, she had no problems but came along well with them. When she was with me together with a dog or two from the outside she still had no problems.
 
However when she, me and Foxy and/or Briz where together, like on the lawn playing with retrieves or something similar, Springer became jealous. I was her master and her master alone, she did not like the other dogs to play with me when she was in the neighbourhood. We had a wonderful relation, we had worked and trained so much together and had had so much success.
 
Since Springer was not the type of dog that bites or growls immediately when stressed, thereby relieving the pressure, she got into a conflict. The conflict consisted of several simultaneous conditions:
 
  I was not playing with her, on the contrary I was playing with the other pack members. From her point of view the universe consisted of her and me together, and any social interference from the outside was inconceivable, a threat towards our relation and her position in the pack.
 
A threat is normally counterattacked with aggression but Springer was not an aggressive dog and in addition she knew that I disliked aggressive behaviour when I was around. When I was not around the condition did not exist and she had no reason to be aggressive....you know what I mean?
 
Anyway she built up pressure and the safety valve could have been any displacement behaviour but she used this one: She ran in circles on the lawn, head low and was constantly trying to grab straws of grass with her teeth. The look on her face also signalled stress and this was not really easy to break until the other dogs were removed. We can go back a few days in time to the message about a Hungarian research suggesting and proving that old dogs have more difficulties to handle stress than younger dogs. Springers sensibility to stress slowly increased with age, I have written about that many times.
 
Finally all this was my own fault, I did not act like a male wolf pack leader would have done, hence I was the cause for Springer's social conflict. I had, as a male wolf, to choose to either let Springer be the alpha bitch beside of me as the alpha male, and keep a distance to the other pack members of lower rank. Springer would have been happy with this. I could also have kept Springer at a lower level, letting Maud be the alpha bitch in our pack. Springer would have been happy with this also.
 
Her conflict was caused by my way of alternatingly letting her be the alpha bitch and then without any warning put her aside for awhile. I guess such behaviour is not found in the ethics books for common dog pack behaviour.
 
Now, my human behaviour is very common among dog owners and some dogs can take it very well while others develop different kinds of symptoms from displacement behaviours to outright aggressively towards the owner.
 
 
Torsti
Borta Med Vindens Kennel
"Ask not what your dog can do for you.
Ask what you can do for your dog."
www.rospigan.net
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Mailing Lists > working-gundog > [working-gundog] displacement behaviours



ActiveForums 3.7
 Private Message Count
Minimize
You must be logged in to use this module.
UsersOnline
Membership Membership:
Latest New User Latest: nellavon
New Today New Today: 2
New Yesterday New Yesterday: 2
User Count Overall: 3253

People Online People Online:
Visitors Visitors: 123
Members Members: 4
Total Total: 127

Online Now Online Now:
01: pixie bee
02: kpwlee
03: iamjanco
04: treed711
 Print   
Home  |  Events  |  Blogs  |  Photo Gallery  |  GSP Forum
 Terms Of Use | Privacy Statement | WHC DNN Site 
Copyright 2008-2011 by Rick Petersen